8+ CA Credit Checks for Employment: Guide


8+ CA Credit Checks for Employment: Guide

In California, evaluating an applicant’s monetary historical past throughout the hiring course of is a regulated follow. This includes reviewing a client report, which can embody credit score historical past, for particular roles and with sure authorized stipulations. For instance, positions dealing with important monetary sources or delicate info would possibly warrant such scrutiny.

This follow goals to mitigate dangers related to embezzlement, fraud, or different monetary malfeasance. It offers employers with further insights into an applicant’s monetary duty and stability, doubtlessly safeguarding firm belongings and popularity. Nonetheless, the state has enacted particular laws to stability employer wants with applicant protections, emphasizing transparency and knowledgeable consent. Traditionally, such screenings have been much less regulated, resulting in considerations about equity and potential discrimination. Authorized frameworks now present higher readability and guarantee a extra equitable hiring panorama.

This text will delve additional into the particular rules governing these screenings, exploring employer obligations, applicant rights, and the potential influence on hiring choices. It’s going to additionally look at greatest practices for implementing these procedures legally and ethically.

1. Authorized Compliance

Authorized compliance varieties the cornerstone of permissible credit score checks for employment in California. Navigating this panorama requires strict adherence to each federal and state legal guidelines, primarily the Truthful Credit score Reporting Act (FCRA) and the California Investigative Shopper Reporting Businesses Act (ICRAA), together with different related statutes. These legal guidelines dictate particular necessities for employers, together with acquiring knowledgeable consent earlier than conducting a credit score examine, offering pre-adverse motion notices, and providing alternatives for candidates to dispute inaccuracies. Failure to conform may end up in important penalties, together with fines and authorized motion. As an example, an employer who runs a credit score examine with out acquiring correct consent or fails to supply required disclosures might face authorized repercussions. This underscores the essential significance of understanding and adhering to authorized mandates.

The ICRAA, for instance, offers stricter pointers than the FCRA concerning permissible functions for credit score checks. Whereas the FCRA permits credit score checks for employment functions typically, the ICRAA limits their use to positions that contain particular standards, akin to dealing with important monetary sources or accessing confidential info. Take into account a situation the place an employer conducts a credit score examine for a low-level, non-sensitive place. This motion may very well be thought of a violation of the ICRAA, even when compliant with the FCRA. This emphasizes the necessity for employers to be meticulously conscious of the particular provisions of California regulation. Moreover, latest amendments and evolving authorized interpretations require fixed vigilance and adaptation to keep up compliance.

In conclusion, authorized compliance isn’t merely a procedural hurdle however a basic moral and operational requirement for conducting credit score checks in California. Understanding and implementing these authorized frameworks safeguards each employers and candidates, fostering a good and clear hiring course of. Ignoring these necessities creates important authorized and reputational dangers, emphasizing the essential want for diligent adherence to the evolving authorized panorama governing credit score checks for employment in California. This necessitates ongoing training and rigorous inner processes to make sure constant compliance.

2. Applicant Rights

Throughout the context of credit score checks for employment in California, applicant rights play a vital position in balancing employer wants with particular person protections. These rights, enshrined in each federal and state laws, guarantee a good and clear course of, safeguarding people from potential discrimination or misuse of their monetary info. Understanding these rights empowers candidates to navigate the hiring course of with confidence and maintain employers accountable for authorized compliance.

  • Knowledgeable Consent

    California regulation mandates that employers get hold of written consent from candidates earlier than conducting a credit score examine. This consent should be clear and conspicuous, separate from some other utility paperwork. For instance, burying the consent inside a prolonged utility kind or combining it with different authorizations could be thought of non-compliant. This requirement ensures candidates are totally conscious of the credit score examine and perceive its potential influence on hiring choices.

  • Pre-Adversarial Motion Discover

    If an employer intends to take opposed motion primarily based on the credit score reportfor instance, not hiring an applicant as a consequence of destructive credit score historythey should first present a pre-adverse motion discover. This discover features a copy of the credit score report and a abstract of rights underneath the FCRA. This permits candidates to evaluation the report for inaccuracies and doubtlessly clarify destructive info earlier than a ultimate choice is made. As an example, an applicant may need been a sufferer of id theft, leading to inaccurate entries on their credit score report. The pre-adverse motion discover offers a vital alternative to handle such discrepancies.

  • Proper to Dispute Inaccuracies

    Candidates have the precise to dispute any inaccurate or incomplete info discovered of their credit score experiences. They will contact the credit score reporting company on to provoke a dispute investigation. If the investigation confirms errors, the company should right the report, and the employer should be notified of the modifications. This proper ensures candidates usually are not unfairly penalized for info that’s not a real reflection of their monetary historical past.

  • Limitations on Use of Credit score Data

    California regulation restricts using credit score info for employment functions. Credit score checks are typically permissible just for positions involving important monetary duty or entry to delicate info. Utilizing credit score checks for roles that don’t meet these standards, akin to entry-level positions with out monetary obligations, might violate applicant rights. This limitation prevents the overuse and potential misuse of credit score info in hiring choices.

These applicant rights are basic to making sure a good and legally compliant hiring course of in California. They empower candidates to know and take part in choices that have an effect on their employment prospects primarily based on credit score info. Upholding these rights fosters a clear and moral hiring atmosphere whereas additionally defending employers from authorized challenges and reputational injury related to non-compliance.

3. Disclosure Necessities

Disclosure necessities are integral to the authorized and moral use of credit score checks for employment in California. These necessities, stemming from each the Truthful Credit score Reporting Act (FCRA) and the California Investigative Shopper Reporting Businesses Act (ICRAA), mandate transparency and supply candidates with essential info concerning using their credit score historical past in hiring choices. This transparency fosters a extra equitable hiring course of and safeguards applicant rights.

A key component of disclosure is the requirement for a standalone disclosure doc. This doc should clearly and conspicuously inform the applicant {that a} credit score report could also be obtained for employment functions. It can’t be embedded inside different utility supplies or mixed with different authorizations. As an example, together with the disclosure inside a common launch kind or burying it inside prolonged phrases and circumstances wouldn’t meet authorized requirements. This separate disclosure ensures candidates explicitly perceive that their credit score historical past will probably be reviewed. Moreover, the disclosure should specify the permissible objective for the credit score examine, linking it on to the necessities of the place, akin to dealing with monetary belongings or delicate info. This readability permits candidates to know the rationale behind the credit score examine and assess its relevance to the job.

Past the preliminary disclosure, additional necessities come into play if an employer intends to take opposed motion primarily based on the credit score report, akin to declining an utility. Earlier than taking such motion, the employer should present a pre-adverse motion discover. This discover features a copy of the buyer report used and a abstract of rights underneath the FCRA. This offers candidates with the chance to evaluation the report for inaccuracies or present context for destructive entries earlier than a ultimate hiring choice is made. Failure to supply these disclosures may end up in substantial penalties for employers and invalidate using the credit score report within the hiring course of. Due to this fact, meticulous adherence to disclosure necessities isn’t merely a authorized formality however a vital facet of accountable and moral hiring practices in California.

4. Permissible Functions

In California, using credit score checks for employment is strictly regulated and restricted to particular permissible functions. This framework, primarily outlined by the California Investigative Shopper Reporting Businesses Act (ICRAA), goals to stability employer wants with applicant protections, stopping indiscriminate use of credit score info in hiring choices. Understanding these permissible functions is essential for each employers and candidates to make sure authorized compliance and honest hiring practices.

  • Positions of Belief and Monetary Duty

    Credit score checks are typically permissible for positions involving a excessive diploma of belief and monetary duty. This contains roles the place workers deal with important quantities of cash, have entry to delicate monetary information, or make monetary choices on behalf of the group. Examples embody accountants, monetary managers, and executives with fiscal oversight. This rationale stems from the potential threat of embezzlement, fraud, or monetary mismanagement, making monetary historical past a related think about assessing suitability for such roles.

  • Entry to Confidential Data

    Credit score checks could also be permissible for positions involving entry to confidential info, together with commerce secrets and techniques, proprietary information, or delicate buyer info. This is applicable to roles the place people might doubtlessly be compromised or coerced as a consequence of monetary vulnerabilities. Examples embody workers with entry to safe databases, analysis and growth personnel, and people dealing with confidential shopper information. This rationale prioritizes the safety of delicate info and mitigates potential dangers related to monetary instability.

  • Administration and Supervisory Roles

    Credit score checks could also be allowed for managerial and supervisory roles, significantly these involving oversight of monetary operations or important firm belongings. This rationale acknowledges the elevated degree of duty and decision-making authority inherent in such positions. As an example, a supervisor overseeing a price range or chargeable for firm property is perhaps topic to a credit score examine. This aligns with the employer’s curiosity in making certain monetary duty and sound judgment in key personnel.

  • State and Native Authorities Exemptions

    Particular exemptions exist for state and native authorities positions, significantly regulation enforcement and public security roles. These exemptions usually replicate the heightened requirements of trustworthiness and reliability required for these essential positions. For instance, a background examine for a regulation enforcement officer could embody a evaluation of credit score historical past as a part of a complete evaluation of suitability for public service. These exemptions underscore the particular issues related to public sector employment.

Understanding these permissible functions offers a framework for evaluating the legitimacy of credit score checks within the California employment context. It emphasizes the significance of aligning credit score checks with particular job necessities and avoiding their use for roles the place monetary historical past isn’t a demonstrably related issue. This method ensures compliance with California regulation, protects applicant rights, and promotes a good and clear hiring course of.

5. Trade Variations

Whereas California regulation offers a common framework for credit score checks in employment, industry-specific elements usually affect how these checks are applied and interpreted. These variations stem from the distinctive nature of sure industries, the particular dangers they face, and the extent of monetary duty entrusted to workers. Understanding these nuances is essential for each employers and candidates to navigate the complexities of credit score checks inside completely different sectors.

  • Monetary Establishments

    The monetary {industry}, together with banks, funding companies, and lending establishments, usually makes use of credit score checks extra extensively than different sectors. This displays the inherent monetary dangers related to managing and dealing with giant sums of cash, delicate monetary information, and shopper belongings. A sturdy credit score historical past is usually thought of a prerequisite for employment in roles involving direct monetary duty or entry to delicate buyer info. As an example, a mortgage officer or a monetary advisor would seemingly bear a radical credit score examine as a part of the hiring course of. This stringent method goals to mitigate the danger of fraud, embezzlement, and different monetary malfeasance.

  • Authorities and Public Sector

    Authorities companies, significantly these concerned in regulation enforcement, public security, and nationwide safety, usually have particular rules and exemptions concerning credit score checks. These checks could also be required for positions involving entry to labeled info, dealing with delicate supplies, or positions of public belief. For instance, a background examine for a regulation enforcement officer or a safety clearance for a authorities worker would possibly contain reviewing credit score historical past. This heightened scrutiny displays the essential nature of those roles and the necessity to guarantee trustworthiness and reliability.

  • Healthcare

    The healthcare {industry}, significantly in roles involving billing, insurance coverage, and entry to affected person monetary info, could make the most of credit score checks to evaluate monetary duty. Whereas not as prevalent as within the monetary sector, these checks will be related for positions the place workers deal with delicate monetary information or work together with sufferers’ monetary data. As an example, a billing specialist or a medical workplace supervisor is perhaps topic to a credit score examine. This follow goals to guard affected person info and preserve the integrity of monetary processes inside healthcare organizations.

  • Know-how and Startups

    The know-how sector, significantly startups and quickly rising corporations, usually displays variations of their method to credit score checks. Whereas some corporations, significantly these coping with monetary transactions or delicate information, could implement credit score checks, others would possibly prioritize abilities and expertise over credit score historical past. This flexibility displays the dynamic nature of the {industry} and the give attention to attracting expertise in a aggressive market. Nonetheless, as these corporations mature and deal with growing quantities of monetary information, using credit score checks would possibly change into extra prevalent.

These {industry} variations spotlight the nuanced relationship between credit score checks and employment in California. Whereas the authorized framework offers a basis, particular {industry} practices and threat assessments usually form the implementation and interpretation of credit score checks. Recognizing these variations is important for each employers and candidates to navigate the hiring course of successfully and guarantee compliance with related rules whereas fostering a good and clear employment panorama.

6. Exemptions and Exceptions

Even inside California’s regulated framework for employment credit score checks, sure exemptions and exceptions exist. These carve-outs acknowledge particular circumstances the place the usual guidelines could not apply, offering nuances to the broader authorized panorama. Understanding these exemptions and exceptions is essential for each employers and candidates to make sure correct interpretation and utility of the regulation.

  • Safety Clearances

    Positions requiring authorities safety clearances, usually involving entry to labeled info or nationwide safety pursuits, could also be exempt from normal credit score examine rules. These clearances sometimes contain a extra complete background investigation, together with monetary historical past, and should adhere to separate federal pointers that supersede state regulation. This exemption acknowledges the heightened safety considerations inherent in such roles and the necessity for a extra rigorous vetting course of.

  • Regulation Enforcement and Public Security

    Sure regulation enforcement and public security positions can also be exempt from normal credit score examine guidelines. The rationale for this exemption usually facilities on the distinctive nature of those roles and the excessive degree of public belief they entail. An intensive background examine, doubtlessly together with credit score historical past evaluation, is perhaps deemed essential to assess suitability for these essential positions. Particular state and native rules usually dictate the scope of those background checks.

  • Chapter Data Restrictions

    Whereas credit score experiences could typically be utilized in hiring choices, sure info, akin to chapter filings older than ten years, is often excluded. This restriction goals to stop discriminatory practices primarily based on previous monetary difficulties which will not replicate an applicant’s present monetary standing. This provision acknowledges the rehabilitative nature of chapter proceedings and promotes a fairer evaluation of candidates.

  • Applicant-Initiated Credit score Studies

    An exception to the usual disclosure and consent necessities arises when an applicant voluntarily offers their very own credit score report back to a possible employer. In such circumstances, the employer could evaluation the supplied report without having to acquire separate consent or present pre-adverse motion notices. Nonetheless, if the employer subsequently decides to acquire a separate credit score report, normal disclosure and authorization procedures should be adopted. This exception acknowledges the applicant’s proactive method in offering info related to their monetary historical past.

These exemptions and exceptions add complexity to the already nuanced panorama of credit score checks for employment in California. Recognizing and understanding these particular circumstances is essential for each employers and candidates to navigate the hiring course of legally and ethically. A cautious and knowledgeable method ensures compliance with the regulation whereas selling a good and clear analysis of candidates. Failure to correctly apply these exemptions and exceptions can result in authorized challenges and doubtlessly jeopardize the validity of hiring choices. Due to this fact, diligent consideration to those nuances is paramount for profitable and legally sound hiring practices in California.

7. Adversarial Motion Processes

Adversarial motion processes are a essential part of legally compliant credit score checks for employment in California. These processes, mandated by the Truthful Credit score Reporting Act (FCRA) and additional outlined by the California Investigative Shopper Reporting Businesses Act (ICRAA), present essential protections for candidates when an employer makes a hiring choice primarily based, in entire or partially, on a client credit score report. The cause-and-effect relationship is evident: if a credit score report influences an opposed hiring choice, particular procedures should be adopted to make sure equity and transparency. For instance, if an applicant is denied a place as a consequence of destructive info revealed in a credit score examine, the employer should adhere to particular opposed motion protocols.

The opposed motion course of unfolds in two key levels. First, the employer should present a pre-adverse motion discover. This discover features a copy of the buyer report used within the decision-making course of and a abstract of rights underneath the FCRA. This permits the applicant a chance to evaluation the report for inaccuracies and supply context or explanations for destructive entries. As an example, an applicant may need been a sufferer of id theft, leading to misguided info on their credit score report. The pre-adverse motion discover offers them an opportunity to handle such points. Following an inexpensive interval, sometimes 5 enterprise days, the employer can proceed with the second stage if the hiring choice stays unchanged. This includes offering an opposed motion discover, formally speaking the choice and reiterating the applicant’s rights. This discover should additionally embody the contact info for the buyer reporting company that furnished the report. This two-step course of ensures candidates have ample alternative to evaluation and dispute doubtlessly damaging info earlier than a ultimate choice is made, selling equity and transparency.

Understanding and implementing opposed motion processes appropriately is essential for employers conducting credit score checks in California. Failure to stick to those procedures can expose employers to authorized challenges, together with fines and potential lawsuits. Furthermore, correct adherence fosters belief and demonstrates a dedication to moral hiring practices. For candidates, understanding these processes empowers them to train their rights and handle any inaccuracies which will have unfairly influenced the hiring choice. The opposed motion course of serves as an important safeguard, making certain that credit score info is used responsibly and pretty within the employment context. It underscores the significance of balancing employer wants with applicant protections, contributing to a extra equitable and legally sound hiring panorama in California. Ignoring these procedures not solely dangers authorized repercussions but in addition undermines the integrity of the hiring course of.

8. Dispute Decision

Dispute decision performs an important position within the context of credit score checks for employment in California. When an applicant believes info inside a client report used for employment functions is inaccurate or incomplete, established procedures present avenues for difficult and doubtlessly correcting the file. This mechanism ensures equity and accuracy throughout the hiring course of, safeguarding applicant rights whereas permitting employers to make the most of credit score info responsibly.

  • Initiating the Dispute

    Candidates can provoke a dispute immediately with the buyer reporting company that furnished the report. This includes offering particular particulars in regards to the disputed info, supporting documentation, and a proper request for investigation. As an example, an applicant would possibly present proof of id theft to problem fraudulent accounts listed on their credit score report. Initiating a dispute prompts the company to research the declare and doubtlessly right the file if inaccuracies are confirmed.

  • Investigation by the Shopper Reporting Company

    Upon receiving a dispute, the buyer reporting company is obligated to research the declare inside an inexpensive timeframe, sometimes 30 days. This investigation includes contacting the furnisher of the knowledge, akin to a creditor or monetary establishment, to confirm the accuracy of the disputed information. The company should then present the applicant with the outcomes of the investigation, together with any modifications made to the credit score report.

  • Employer Notification and Reconsideration

    If the buyer reporting company confirms inaccuracies and modifies the credit score report, the employer who obtained the unique report should be notified of the modifications. This notification permits the employer to rethink the hiring choice primarily based on the up to date info. For instance, if an preliminary opposed motion was primarily based on inaccurate credit score info, the employer would possibly rethink the applying after the correction.

  • Additional Dispute Decision Choices

    If the applicant stays unhappy with the result of the company’s investigation, additional dispute decision choices exist. These could embody submitting a criticism with the Shopper Monetary Safety Bureau (CFPB) or pursuing authorized motion in opposition to the buyer reporting company or the furnisher of the incorrect info. These avenues present further recourse for candidates searching for to right errors and handle potential hurt brought on by inaccurate reporting.

The provision of sturdy dispute decision mechanisms is important to the integrity and equity of credit score checks for employment in California. These procedures empower candidates to problem inaccuracies and make sure that employment choices are primarily based on correct and dependable info. This not solely protects applicant rights but in addition reinforces employer compliance with related rules, fostering a extra clear and equitable hiring atmosphere. The emphasis on dispute decision contributes considerably to the general stability between employer wants and applicant protections within the context of credit score checks for employment in California. It offers a essential security internet, making certain that using credit score info stays a good and legally sound part of the hiring course of.

Incessantly Requested Questions

This part addresses frequent inquiries concerning using credit score experiences in employment choices inside California.

Query 1: Are all employers in California permitted to conduct credit score checks on candidates?

No. California regulation restricts using credit score experiences for employment functions. Usually, credit score checks are permissible just for positions involving important monetary duty, entry to delicate info, or managerial/supervisory roles assembly particular standards.

Query 2: What rights do candidates have concerning credit score checks in California?

Candidates have a number of key rights, together with the precise to obtain clear and conspicuous disclosure earlier than a credit score examine is performed, the precise to obtain a pre-adverse motion discover if a destructive choice is made primarily based on the report, and the precise to dispute inaccuracies discovered throughout the report.

Query 3: Can an employer deny employment solely primarily based on a credit score report?

Whereas a credit score report is usually a think about hiring choices, California regulation typically prohibits employers from denying employment solely primarily based on credit score info until the destructive info immediately pertains to the particular duties and obligations of the place.

Query 4: What recourse do candidates have in the event that they consider a credit score report used in opposition to them is inaccurate?

Candidates can dispute inaccuracies immediately with the buyer reporting company that furnished the report. The company is legally obligated to research the dispute and proper any confirmed errors. Candidates may file complaints with the Shopper Monetary Safety Bureau (CFPB) or pursue authorized motion if needed.

Query 5: How lengthy can destructive info stay on a credit score report and doubtlessly have an effect on employment prospects?

Most destructive info stays on a credit score report for seven years, though bankruptcies can stay for as much as ten years. Nonetheless, the influence of this info on hiring choices diminishes over time, and employers are inspired to contemplate the age and relevance of destructive entries.

Query 6: Are there particular industries in California the place credit score checks are extra frequent?

Sure. Credit score checks are extra prevalent in industries like monetary providers, the place workers usually deal with giant sums of cash or delicate monetary information. They’re additionally frequent in authorities and public security roles, the place background checks usually embody a evaluation of monetary historical past.

Understanding these continuously requested questions offers beneficial insights into the authorized and sensible features of credit score checks for employment in California. Staying knowledgeable about applicant rights, employer obligations, and accessible dispute decision mechanisms helps guarantee a good and clear hiring course of for everybody concerned.

For additional info and particular authorized steering, consulting with an employment legal professional or reviewing the related statutes and rules is really useful.

Ideas for Navigating Credit score Checks in California Employment

This part presents sensible steering for each employers and candidates navigating the complexities of credit score checks throughout the California employment panorama.

Tip 1: Perceive the Authorized Framework. Completely familiarize your self with the Truthful Credit score Reporting Act (FCRA), the California Investigative Shopper Reporting Businesses Act (ICRAA), and different related state and federal legal guidelines governing using client experiences for employment functions. This foundational information is essential for compliance and honest practices.

Tip 2: Set up Clear, Written Insurance policies. Employers ought to develop complete written insurance policies outlining the particular circumstances underneath which credit score checks will probably be performed, the forms of positions that warrant such checks, and the procedures for acquiring consent and dealing with opposed actions. This promotes consistency and transparency.

Tip 3: Guarantee Correct Disclosure and Consent. Present candidates with a transparent and conspicuous standalone disclosure doc informing them of the intent to conduct a credit score examine. Acquire written consent earlier than procuring a report, making certain compliance with authorized necessities.

Tip 4: Restrict Credit score Checks to Permissible Functions. Limit using credit score checks to positions the place monetary duty, entry to delicate info, or managerial oversight are demonstrably related. Keep away from utilizing credit score checks for roles the place such info isn’t a justifiable think about hiring choices.

Tip 5: Implement a Truthful and Constant Course of. Apply credit score examine insurance policies uniformly throughout all candidates for related positions to keep away from potential discrimination claims. Be sure that credit score info is taken into account alongside different related elements within the general analysis course of.

Tip 6: Present Pre-Adversarial and Adversarial Motion Notices. If a hiring choice is influenced negatively by info in a credit score report, meticulously observe pre-adverse and opposed motion procedures, offering candidates with copies of the report, summaries of their rights, and call info for the reporting company.

Tip 7: Respect Applicant Rights and Privateness. Deal with applicant credit score info with confidentiality and respect. Retailer and get rid of credit score experiences securely to guard delicate information and preserve privateness.

Tip 8: Search Authorized Counsel When Obligatory. Seek the advice of with authorized counsel specializing in employment regulation to make sure compliance with evolving rules and handle advanced conditions or potential disputes. This proactive method mitigates authorized dangers and promotes greatest practices.

By adhering to those suggestions, each employers and candidates can navigate the complexities of credit score checks for employment in California with higher confidence and readability. These pointers promote authorized compliance, equity, and transparency all through the hiring course of.

This detailed exploration of credit score checks in California employment concludes with a abstract of key takeaways and a name to motion.

California Credit score Verify Employment

Navigating California credit score examine employment practices requires cautious consideration of a fancy regulatory panorama. This text has explored the multifaceted nature of such checks, emphasizing the stability between employer wants and applicant rights. Key takeaways embody the strict limitations on permissible functions, the significance of knowledgeable consent and disclosure, and the particular procedures for opposed motion. Moreover, the exploration of {industry} variations, exemptions, and dispute decision processes underscores the nuanced utility of those rules. An intensive understanding of those components is essential for each employers searching for to mitigate threat and candidates safeguarding their rights.

The evolving authorized and regulatory panorama surrounding California credit score examine employment necessitates ongoing vigilance. Staying knowledgeable about legislative updates, judicial interpretations, and greatest practices is paramount. The accountable use of credit score info in hiring choices requires a dedication to equity, transparency, and strict adherence to authorized mandates. Finally, fostering a balanced and equitable method advantages each employers and candidates, contributing to a extra strong and moral employment atmosphere in California. This requires steady adaptation and a proactive dedication to compliance, making certain that using credit score info stays a good and legally sound part of the hiring course of.